All-Stars brought eighteen returning players back to the Pearl Islands in three tribes of six, and the former winners did not last. Tina went first, 4–2, and Jenna M. quit on day 9. Richard was voted out 6–1 on day 15 and Ethan 4–1 on day 21. By the end of the third week every past winner in the cast was gone.
Saboga, which lost the first two votes, was dissolved into the other two tribes on day 13 after losing a reward challenge. Sue quit on day 17, two days after Richard left, and Mogo Mogo voted out Colby 3–2 and then Ethan. A second shuffle on day 22 set up new tribes of five, and the new Chapera sent Jerri home 4–1. The shuffle split Boston Rob and Amber, who had paired up early in the game, but both reached the merge.
Nine players merged into Chaboga Mogo. Lex fell 7–2 and Kathy 6–2 a day later, both times with Amber drawing the only other votes, then Alicia, Shii Ann and Tom went home. Rob won four individual immunities and Amber two. Rupert went 3–1 at the final four, and Rob, holding the last immunity, voted out Jenna L. to sit beside Amber. The jury chose Amber Mariano 4–3, with Alicia, Lex, Shii Ann and Tom voting for her. Rob proposed to her at the live finale.

















