Heroes vs. Villains marked the show's twentieth season by bringing back twenty former players and sorting them into ten Heroes and ten Villains according to how they had played before. The Heroes lost four of the first five Tribal Councils. Sugar went first, 9–1, then Stephenie. On day 11 Tom played an idol that cancelled three votes, but Cirie went home 3–2 instead, and Tom himself was gone three days later.
The Villains had their own fights. At a double Tribal Council on day 15, Russell played an idol for Parvati that cancelled four votes, and Tyson left on a 3–2 count. Russell's side then beat Boston Rob's, 4–3–1 on day 18, and Coach went out 4–3 soon after. The tribes merged at ten, five a side. By then J.T. had found an idol and handed it to Russell, who passed it to Parvati. On day 27 Parvati played two idols, one for Jerri and one for Sandra. Five Heroes votes were cancelled, and J.T. went home on the five Villains votes.
From there the Villains held control. Amanda, Candice, Danielle, Rupert and Colby went out over the next five votes, Danielle 4–3 on day 33, and Jerri fell 3–1 at the final four. Parvati won four individual immunities and Russell three. The jury, though, gave Sandra six votes to Parvati's three, with none for Russell. Sandra, who had won Pearl Islands, became the first person to win the game twice.



















