Redemption Island brought back two returning players, Boston Rob on Ometepe and Russell on Zapatera, and changed what a vote meant: each person voted out moved to Redemption Island to fight duels there, and winning them could lead back into the game. Russell's stay was short. Zapatera deadlocked 3–3–3 on day 8, and Russell went out 5–1 on the revote. Ometepe had lost Francesca 4–3–2 on day 3, Matt on day 5 and Kristina 4–3 on day 11, but after that Zapatera lost three straight votes, sending Krista, Stephanie and Sarita away.
Matt won his way back from Redemption Island for the merge, only to be voted out again on day 21 by a close 6–5–1. From there Zapatera's Mike, David and Julie went out in turn. On day 30 a double elimination took Ralph 6–2 and Steve 6–1. Ralph had earlier played the idol he found without a clue, but it was not needed. Andrea was voted out on day 32, came back through Redemption Island, and was voted out a second time at the final five.
Rob won four individual immunities, including the last one on day 38, and also played the idol he had found on day 10 at the final five. Grant went 4–1 and Ashley 3–1 on the way to the end. The jury voted 8–1–0 for Rob over Phillip and Natalie, with only Ralph backing Phillip. On his fourth time playing, Boston Rob was finally the Sole Survivor.

















