Cook Islands started twenty players in four tribes of five divided by ethnicity, a format that drew heavy criticism before the season aired. Manihiki voted out Sekou 3–2 and Aitutaki lost Billy 4–1, and on day 7 a schoolyard pick folded the four tribes into two, Aitutaki and Rarotonga. They traded losses evenly, with each side voting out three before the next twist.
On day 20 the castaways were offered a mutiny. Candice and Jonathan jumped from Aitutaki to Rarotonga, leaving four on Aitutaki: Yul, Ozzy, Becky and Sundra. The Aitu Four kept winning, and Rarotonga voted out Brad 7–1, then Rebecca and Jenny in a double elimination on day 24.
At the merge the Aitu Four were outnumbered five to four, but one vote crossed over and Nate went home 5–4. Candice, one of the mutineers, went 5–3 next, then Jonathan, Parvati and Adam. Ozzy won five of the six individual immunities after the merge. At the final four Becky and Sundra tied 2–2, and Sundra lost the fire-making tie-breaker. Yul, who held a super idol for most of the game and never played it, won the show's first three-person final Tribal Council 5–4–0 over Ozzy and Becky. Adam, Brad, Candice, Jonathan and Sundra voted for him.



















