South Pacific went back to Samoa and put one returning player on each tribe of new castaways, Ozzy on Savaii and Coach on Upolu. Redemption Island was in play again. Savaii lost four of the seven votes before the merge, Semhar, Papa Bear, Elyse and finally Ozzy, while Upolu lost Christine, Stacey and Mikayla. Ozzy's exit on day 18 was a 5–1 vote by his own tribe, a deliberate move to send him to Redemption Island. He left his idol with Cochran, won his way back at the merge, and had the idol again by day 19.
The merge was even at six apiece, and the first vote tied 6–6 between Rick and Keith. On the revote Cochran crossed to the Upolu side and Keith went out 6–4. After that Upolu's alliance, The Family, kept control. Ozzy was voted out again 9–2 on day 22, Jim went 7–3, and a double elimination on day 27 took Dawn and Whitney by 7–2 and 7–1. Cochran followed 5–2 on day 30, and Edna and Brandon went next.
Ozzy fought back through Redemption Island a second time and won immunity on day 37, when Rick left 3–2. He was voted out 3–1 the next day after Sophie won the final challenge, her third individual immunity. Coach never played the idol he had found on day 12. At the Final Tribal Council Sophie took six of the nine votes, beating Coach 6–3, and Albert received none.

















