Island of the Idols sent 20 new players to Fiji on two tribes of ten. Past winners Boston Rob and Sandra lived on a separate island as mentors, testing the players sent to visit them. Lairo had the harder start, losing Ronnie 7–2, Vince 5–3–1 and Chelsea 6–2, while Vokai lost only Molly. Vince and Chelsea both left with idols in their bags.
A day 12 swap reset the two tribes. Tom went next, then Jason, 4–3, after Elaine blocked his vote. On day 19 Dean played an idol that cancelled five votes, and Jack went home on the two that counted. The merged Lumuwaku tribe opened by voting out Kellee 8–5 while she held two idols. A split Tribal on day 27 took Aaron and Missy, and on day 30 Karishma's idol cancelled seven votes before Elizabeth lost a revote.
The endgame was overshadowed on day 36, when Dan Spilo was ejected from the game, a first for the show. At final five Janet played her idol, but Dean nullified it and she went home. Noura won the last immunity and took Tommy to the final three, and Dean beat Lauren at fire. Tommy took 8 of the 10 jury votes, Dean got 2 and Noura none.



















