Panama, back in the Pearl Islands, opened with four tribes of four split by age and gender: older women on Casaya, younger women on Bayoneta, younger men on Viveros and older men on La Mina. After one vote, Tina 3–1, a schoolyard pick folded them into two tribes, and the unpicked player went to Exile Island. Terry found a special idol on Exile on day 9, good through the final four.
The new La Mina lost Misty, Ruth Marie and Dan, and Casaya voted out Melinda and Bobby, so the merge had six Casaya and four La Mina. Casaya took Nick 6–4, Austin 6–3 and Sally 6–2. The one La Mina player it could not touch was Terry, who won immunity at five straight Tribal Councils. Bruce was medically evacuated on day 25.
With only Terry left from La Mina, Casaya turned on itself. Courtney went 3–2–1 and Shane 3–1–1. Aras won immunity at the final four, where Cirie and Danielle tied 2–2 and Cirie lost the fire-making tie-breaker. Danielle won the last immunity and voted out Terry, who never played his idol. Aras Baskauskas beat Danielle 5–2, with Bruce and Shane the only votes for her.















