Blood vs. Water set ten returning players on Galang against their loved ones on Tadhana, with Redemption Island in play. The twist hit on day 1, when each tribe voted someone out on first impressions and the loved one could trade places with them. Tadhana voted out Laura B., and her husband Rupert took her place on Redemption Island while she joined Galang. Galang voted out Candice.
Tadhana then lost the next four votes: Marissa 8–1, Rachel, John, and Brad after a 3–3 tie with Ciera. Galang lost Colton when he quit on day 7, but did not vote anyone else out until day 13, when Laura M. went 7–1. After a swap on day 14, the new Galang voted out Kat and Laura B. The merged Kasama tribe then voted out brothers Aras 7–2–2 and Vytas 8–1–1 on back-to-back nights. Tina went 7–1–1 on day 24, and Laura M., back from Redemption Island, left again 7–1.
On day 32 Hayden and Monica tied 3–3, then 2–2 on the revote, and the vote went to rocks. Katie drew the odd one and was out. Hayden went 3–2 three days later. At the final five Tyson played his second idol for Gervase, cancelling two votes, and Ciera went home with three. Tina, who had won her way back from Redemption Island, fell 3–1 at the final four. The jury voted 7–1–0 for Tyson over Monica and Gervase, with only Vytas voting for Monica.



















