Winners at War marked the show's 40th season with 20 past winners on two tribes of ten and a $2 million prize. The Edge of Extinction returned, now with fire tokens, a currency players could spend on food and advantages. Natalie was voted out first, 7–2–1 on day 2, and Amber followed the next day. Danni, Ethan and Tyson went before a day 12 swap formed a third tribe.
The swap did not slow the exits of big names. Boston Rob went 4–1 and Parvati 3–2, and Sandra left on a single vote after Denise played two idols to protect herself and Jeremy. Tyson won his way back at the merge, only to be voted out a second time on day 25, 5–2. Sophie, Kim, Jeremy and Nick followed. At final six Tony, Ben and Natalie all played idols, every vote was cancelled, and Denise went home on the revote.
Natalie, out since day 2, won the second return challenge and found two idols in the final days. She won the last immunity and took Michele to the final three, leaving Tony to beat Sarah, his partner in the Cops-R-Us alliance, at fire. Tony, who won four immunities, took the jury 12–4–0 over Natalie, with Michele shut out, and joined Sandra as a two-time winner.



















