Pearl Islands took sixteen new players to Panama and gave the game a pirate theme. Morgan lost the first three votes: Nicole 7–1, Ryan S. 5–2 and then Lillian, a 51-year-old from Ohio. Drake went to the next four Tribal Councils and lost Burton, Michelle, Trish and Shawn, and Osten quit Morgan on day 19, the same night Shawn went home.
The big twist was the Outcasts. Players who had been voted out lived together as their own tribe and competed for a way back, and two of them, Lillian and Burton, rejoined the game at the merge. The merged tribe, Balboa, voted out Andrew 6–4, then Ryan O. 8–1 and Rupert 5–2–1. Tijuana and Christa went next.
Darrah won three straight immunities, but Burton went 3–2 at the final five and Darrah 3–1 at the final four. Lillian won the last immunity and voted out Jonny Fairplay, the player best remembered for falsely claiming his grandmother had died. Sandra Diaz-Twine then beat Lillian 6–1, with only Tijuana voting for Lillian. Not one vote was cast against Sandra all season.















