Caramoan pitted ten new players, the Gota tribe, against ten returning players on Bikal. Francesca was the first person voted out for the second time in her two seasons, 6–4 on day 3. After that the newcomers struggled. Gota lost Allie, then Hope after a three-way 3–3–3 tie, then Laura, and Shamar was medically evacuated on day 10. Bikal's only other early loss was Brandon, voted out 8–1 on day 13.
A swap on day 14 mixed the tribes, and the new Bikal lost Matt and then Julia after a 3–3 tie. The tribes merged as Enil Edam at twelve, and Corinne went out 7–5, then Michael 7–3–1. On day 28 Malcolm played two idols, one for himself and one for Eddie. Six votes were cancelled, and Phillip went home on the four that counted. Two days later a 3–3–3 tie between Malcolm, Reynold and Andrea ended with Malcolm out on a 6–0 revote.
Reynold went next, and on day 33 Andrea was voted out holding an idol that Erik had found and passed to her two days earlier. Erik was then medically evacuated on day 36, the same day Brenda left. Cochran, back after South Pacific, won three individual immunities, including the last one, and did not receive a single vote at any Tribal Council all season. The jury made it unanimous: eight votes for Cochran, none for Dawn or Sherri.



















