Cagayan divided eighteen new players into three tribes of six by brawn, brains and beauty. The brains tribe, Luzon, went to three of the first four Tribal Councils. David went on day 3, and Garrett, who had found an idol on day 1, was voted out 3–2 on day 6 without playing it. J'Tia followed 3–1 on day 11. The beauty tribe, Solana, lost Brice after a three-way 2–2–2 tie, and the brawn tribe, Aparri, never voted anyone out before Luzon was broken up on day 12.
After the shake-up, Cliff went out 4–3, Lindsey quit on day 14 and Alexis left 6–1. Eleven players merged into Solarrion, and at the first vote Tony and LJ each played an idol for the other. Neither was needed, and Sarah, Tony's partner in the Cops-R-Us alliance, went out 6–5. Tony kept collecting power after that. He found a super idol on day 28 and another idol from an auction clue on day 29. Morgan, LJ, Jeremiah and Jefra went out over the next four votes.
Tasha and Spencer each won three individual immunities, but neither reached the end. Tasha went 4–1–1 on day 33, Trish 4–1 on day 36 and Spencer 3–1 on day 37. Woo won the final challenge on day 38 and cast the only vote at the final three, sending Kass home and keeping Tony. The jury voted 8–1 for Tony, with only Tasha backing Woo. Tony won without a single individual immunity win.

















