San Juan del Sur brought nine pairs of loved ones into the game, split across two tribes of nine, with Exile Island back in use. Coyopa went to the first three Tribal Councils. Nadiya, Natalie's twin sister, went first, 5–3–1. Val left after a 4–4 tie with Baylor, and John was voted out 5–2 on day 8 with an idol he never played. Hunahpu's only early loss was Drew, 5–2–1–1 on day 10.
After a swap on day 11 the new Coyopa voted out Kelley and then her father Dale, and Julie quit on day 18. The merged Huyopa tribe started at eleven, and Josh went out 6–5, followed by Jeremy 5–3–2. Day 26 brought a double idol play. Keith and Jon both played idols, cancelling seven votes between them, and Wes, Keith's son, went home on the two that counted. Reed and Alec followed.
On day 35 Keith, Jaclyn and Jon tied 2–2–2, and Jon went out 2–1 on the revote with an idol still unplayed. Natalie had found an idol on day 25 and held it until the final five, when she played it for Jaclyn. Three votes were cancelled, and Baylor went home with two. Keith, the winner of three individual immunities, went out 3–1 at the final four. The jury chose Natalie 5–2–1 over Jaclyn and Missy.

















