Redemption took 24 castaways to Upolu, Samoa, for 45 days, with four returning players, Harry, Mark, Simon and Brooke, spread across the Bounty and Barren tribes. Bounty struggled early. It lost Daniel 11–1, Eliza 8–3 and Paula 7–2–1, and then Harry went 7–1 on day 11, while Barren gave up only Cat and Johnson. Brooke and Lyndl, on opposite tribes, each found an idol that could only be played at the other camp, and they traded them. Lyndl was voted out on day 16 with the idol Brooke had given her still unplayed.
A shuffle on day 13 reset the tribes. Brooke's idol cancelled three votes on day 20, and Aisha went home 4–1–1 holding an idol she had found that same day. The merged Togiola tribe opened by voting out Lottie 9–3–1. Mark then played an idol that cancelled eight votes as Richard left, but Mark went out 5–4–2 on day 30. Keeley played an idol for Brooke on day 32, cancelling four votes as Blanche went. Simon, who won four individual immunities, more than anyone, left on day 36 after a 4–4 tie with Loz and a 4–2 revote. Brooke followed 4–2 on day 40.
At the final four, Sally and Caleb tied 2–2, and Sally went out in the fire challenge. Caleb then won the last immunity and sent Loz to the jury. That was his only individual win of the game. He beat Jackson 6–3, with returnee Mark among his six votes, while Ben, Brooke and Simon voted for Jackson.



