New Zealand's first season took 16 players to San Juan del Sur, Nicaragua, for 40 days, and it started with a shock. Each tribe voted someone out on day 1, Hannah 7–1 from Mogoton and Dee 7–1 from Hermosa. Mogoton kept losing, with Tony going 4–2–1 and Izzy 3–2–1, and both times Tom was among those receiving votes. Lou was medically evacuated on day 10, and a buff draw on day 11 rebuilt the tribes, with Shannon drawing the black buff and spending two days on Redemption Island before joining Hermosa.
Redemption Island meant a vote did not always end a game, and Shay, Mike and Nate each appear twice in the voting record. Shay lost a 3–2 vote on day 16 but was back by the Casar merge and survived both Tribal Councils on day 20, where Lee went 6–4 and Mike 6–3. Tom took over the challenges after that, winning five individual immunities and holding it at five of the nine merged votes, while Sala, Jak and Shannon went out in turn.
The final four were Nate, Tom, Barb and Avi, and Nate went out on day 38 with Avi holding immunity. At the final Tribal Council Avi won 6–1–0, taking every jury vote except Jak's, which went to Tom. Barb received none.















